Ask the Commish.Com

The Fantasy Advisors

     

NFL Schedule 
Date/Time   Game
9/4/2025 12:00:00 AM: 8:20 PM    DAL @ PHI
9/5/2025 12:00:00 AM: 8:00 PM    KC @ LAC
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    MIA @ IND
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    LV @ NE
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    PIT @ NYJ
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    CLE @ CIN
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    CAR @ JAC
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    NYG @ WAS
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    TB @ ATL
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 1:00 PM    ARI @ NO
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 4:05 PM    TEN @ DEN
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 4:05 PM    SF @ SEA
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 4:25 PM    HOU @ LAR
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 4:25 PM    DET @ GB
9/7/2025 12:00:00 AM: 8:20 PM    BAL @ BUF
9/8/2025 12:00:00 AM: 8:15 PM    MIN @ CHI

See the Entire NFL Schedule

 

Sit or Start for Week 1

Check out our Weekly Best Bets!

Sit AARON RODGERS vs Jets

 
Name recognition and dreams of past performance led Rodgers to be over-drafted in many leagues in 2023. Fantasy owners wised up in 2024 as Rodgers was drafted as a mid-range QB2 in the double-digit rounds of one-quarterback leagues. The good news is that Rodgers is expected to be fully recovered from his torn Achilles when the season starts, but he's still a 40-year-old QB who has thrown one pass in an NFL game in the last 18 months (and was kept in wraps throughout preseason). That combined with an opening game at San Francisco, who ranked #2 against fantasy QBs in 2023, means we really don't want to trust him as a starter at the beginning of the season. Still, with Garrett Wilson as his WR1, Breece Hall as a great pass-catching back, and the potential of Mike Williams and Malachi Corley, Rodgers does have some potential upside if he still has it.

Player Expected Output
Comp.Att.Comp %Pass YdsRush YdsTDsINTs
17.8829.3760.8719360.930.51

Risks...

JACOBY BRISSETT vs Saints
- Brissett joined the New England Patriots this offseason and he'll provide veteran leadership for Drake Maye. We are currently projecting Maye to start more games in 2024 than Brissett but Brissett will start Week 1. He's likely on squads in Superflex leagues and we won't view him as a great starter even in that format. In 11 starts in 2022, he averaged just 17.5 Fantasy points per game and he had a true No. 1 receiver on that roster in Amari Cooper, something the Patriots look like they're without.

Patrick Mahomes vs Chargers
- Mahomes was one of the top 4 quarterbacks taken in Fantasy drafts. To some, that could be surprising since he was 10th among passers last season with just 20.9 Fantasy points per game. But others who choose to look forward will acknowledge new Chiefs wide receivers Marquise "Hollywood" Brown and rookie Xavier Worthy as reasons why Mahomes' numbers could resurge. Both wideouts offer impressive speed and can stretch defenses, perfect for Mahomes to either connect for splash plays or find wide-open options closer to the line of scrimmage. And if Travis Kelce isn't forced to play through injuries like he did last year, Mahomes' receiving corps will be quite strong. Frankly, no elite-tier quarterback saw his situation improve more than Mahomes this offseason, a scary thought for his opponents and a magnificent thought for those who have him in their lineups. That said, temper your expectations for Week 1. First, the Chiefs under Andy Reid have notoriously started off the season slowly. Second, Mahomes will be without Hollywood Brown this week. Lastly, the Ravens have a stout defense and will be looking for revenge for the Chiefs whipping them in the AFC Championship game months ago. The Ravens ranked #2 in passing TDs allowed and #1 against fantasy QBs in 2023.

Kyler Murray vs Saints
- Optimism is high for Murray to return to his top-10 Fantasy QB form now that he's completely over his ACL rehab from 2023 and is armed with outstanding rookie wide receiver Marvin Harrison Jr. in the Cardinals passing game. In eight starts last season, Murray averaged 20.8 Fantasy points per game, notching at least 22 in half of them. That was good for 11th-best among quarterbacks in that time frame, continuing his trend of being a top-12 finisher in per-game Fantasy average (he was ninth in 2022 and seventh in 2021 and 2020). He is a worthy starter in one QB leagues if you decided to wait late to address the QB position and an every-week starter in Superflex/two-QB drafts. This first week may be a tough one as the Cardinals must travel across country to meet the Bills, who ranked #3 in passing TDs allowed in 2023, in an early time zone.

DAK PRESCOTT vs Eagles
- Prescott was a top 5 fantasy QB in most formats in 2023 -- but will he repeat in 2024? His ADP as QB9, suggests that most fantasy owners think not. If you wanted to look for reasons Prescott won't repeat, you start with his 6.1% pass TD rate, which was about a point higher than his career average. However, he's been at 6% for three years now. The truth is, he has essentially been a top-five Fantasy quarterback since the start of 2020, except for 2022 which was marred by injury and some terrible turnover luck. And if you were worried about CeeDee Lamb's status, be happy to know that he is back in the fold after signing a huge contract. So if you did draft him as a QB9 or later, you may have received pretty good value here. You are probably starting him this week in most formats, but he wary of him in DFS as he faces the Browns, who ranked #2 in passing yards allowed in 2023.

Brock Purdy vs Seahawks
- Easily one of the most efficient quarterbacks in the league, Purdy has solidified himself as a solid Fantasy QB thanks to averaging close to 20 Fantasy points in each of his first two seasons. In fact he's hit that 20-point mark in nearly 70% of his regular-season games. It's not because of volume -- Purdy averaged 27.8 passes per game last year, putting him 22nd among 23 qualifiers in the stat. It's what he does with the ball: Purdy was first among qualifying passers in yards per attempt (9.6), second in TD rate (7.0%) and second in completion rate (69.4%). In fact if he threw more passes more often, he'd challenge to be among the best quarterbacks in Fantasy. As it stands, he's consistent with a high floor in any matchup with high scoring potential. That said, as good he has been, there is a ceiling to his talent level, which is why he is largely viewed as a "system" QB in Shanahan's offense, surrounded by elite talent. That elite talent could be slow to start the season as Aiyuk was a holdout until just last week (as was OT Trent Williams) and rookie Pearsall will be on the shelf for at least the next 4 weeks after a horrific shooting incident. Note also that Purdy will face an elite Jets defense that ranked #3 in passing yards allowed and #4 against fantasy QBs in 2023.

Anthony Richardson Sr. vs Dolphins
- Richardson's combination of arm strength, arm talent, and rushing upside earned him a top-10 ranking across the board from our experts heading into his first NFL season. Richardson was a Fantasy superstar immediately, averaging 25.9 points per game in his two full starts. This would put him on pace to be the QB1 overall over a full season. Of course, Richardson didn't play a full season and instead suffered a season-ending shoulder injury in Week 5. In 2024, Richardson was once again one of the highest-upside QBs in Fantasy Football, but he will carry a boom-or-bust profile due to his injury profile. The Colts added Adonai Mitchell at WR in the draft and Richardson will get the benefit of playing with Jonathan Taylor in 2024. If he stays healthy, Richardson will be a league-winning player. He will start this season with a tough draw facing the Texans (who knocked him out last season) and ranked #1 in passing TDs allowed in 2023. For what it is worth, when he played the Texans, he passed for just 56 yards and tossed 0 TD passes -- so there is a good chance that much of his fantasy production will have to come on the ground.

Bryce Young vs Jaguars
- Young finished 30th in Fantasy points per game as a rookie behind the likes of Zach Wilson and Aidan O'Connell. In 2024, his outlook has changed due to the significant investment the Panthers made to surround Young with more help. For starters, the Panthers hired Dave Cana


Start Jordan Love vs Lions

 
Love did more than hold his own in his first year as the starter in Green Bay in 2023. He proved to be a star, and Fantasy managers benefitted in a big way. This season, Love was drafted as a No. 1 Fantasy quarterback in most leagues. Last year, Love took over for Aaron Rodgers and averaged 22.5 Fantasy points per game, including seven outings with at least 26.3 Fantasy points. He did an amazing job spreading the ball around to a diverse receiving corps that's loaded with talent, and all of those weapons return in 2024, hopefully with a fully healthy Christian Watson. There's a lot to love about Love this year -- and we really LOVE him this week. He will face a team that ranked #31 in passing TDs allowed and ranked #32 against fantasy QBs in 2023.

Player Expected Output
Comp.Att.Comp %Pass YdsRush YdsTDsINTs
20.6633.5661.5625881.340.74

Start BAKER MAYFIELD vs Falcons

 
Mayfield had a major bounceback season in 2023 while finding an immediate rapport with Mike Evans. He finished the season as Fantasy QB11 in typical scoring, passing for over 4000 yards. Mayfield will benefit from having another offseason to improve his rapport with Evans and with Chris Godwin now one full year removed from an ACL tear and a hopefully healthier Tampa offensive line. Mayfield makes for a solid backup in one-QB leagues and a QB2 for two-QB and Superflex formats. He should start off the season strong against a suspect Washington defense. The Commanders ranked #32 in passing TDs allowed, #32 in passing yards allowed and #31 against fantasy QBs in 2023. We love his value in DFS this week.

Player Expected Output
Comp.Att.Comp %Pass YdsRush YdsTDsINTs
24.3233.8271.91244172.611.37

Start MATTHEW STAFFORD vs Texans

 
At 36 years old, this might be Stafford's last shot at being a quality Fantasy option. His past two seasons have been very up-and-down but he finished 2023 with 23.4 Fantasy points per game in his final seven when both he and his O-line were healthy. He, like Fantasy managers, benefited from the ascension of Puka Nacua, plus he's got supreme confidence in Cooper Kupp. If he can keep that momentum going with a unit that added guard Jonah Jackson to better protect him, then there's potential for another good season. Shootouts in the NFC West would further pad his stats. Best of all, Stafford is nowhere close to being drafted as a top-12 Fantasy passer, making him an outrageous bargain pick as either a late-round backup in one-QB leagues or a sneaky-good No. 2 QB after the first 15 passers in Superflex/two-QB leagues. Start him with confidence (especially in DFS) this week. He will face his former team (the Lions) that ranked #28 against fantasy QBs in 2023.

Player Expected Output
Comp.Att.Comp %Pass YdsRush YdsTDsINTs
19.7433.5358.8723932.040.68

Rewards...

Josh Allen vs Ravens
- Allen has been the best quarterback in Fantasy Football for the past four seasons, but he's not our consensus No. 1 QB in 2024. This offseason the Bills lost Stefon Diggs and Gabe Davis from their receiving corps and replaced them with Keon Coleman, Curtis Samuel, and Marquez Valdes-Scantling. They also retained Joe Brady as their offensive coordinator. Under Brady, Allen averaged 2.5 fewer pass attempts and 18 fewer pass yards per game. That didn't matter last year, because Allen ran for 15 touchdowns, but we don't want to count on any QB repeating that type of outlier season. You probably drafted Allen as the first or second quarterback in your Fantasy draft, so don't get cute to start the season. He should be a NO BRAIN start this week and every week unless he is on a bye or injured. Note also that in the Cardinals he faces a team that that ranked #30 in passing TDs allowed and was #29 against fantasy QBs in 2023.

Jayden Daniels vs Giants
- Daniels enters the NFL with as much Fantasy Football upside as a quarterback possibly could. He showed that upside in his final season at LSU when he threw 40 touchdown passes and ran for another 11. But this isn't just about him being older than his competition, as Daniels averaged 8.7 yards per pass attempt over 338 attempts as a 19-year-old freshman at Arizona State as well. Now he arrives in Washington with Terry McLaurin to help him excel in the NFL. Positive camp reports led Daniels to be drafted as a top 12 QB in many formats (in Dynasty, Daniels was in consideration for the 1.01 in Superflex leagues). Just know that if he hits his true ceiling, we'll probably feel silly for putting anyone in front of him! He will face a team that ranked #30 in passing yards allowed in 2023.

Jalen Hurts vs Cowboys
- In most formats, Hurts was drafted as a top-three quarterback. Hurts' passing efficiency took a step back in 2023, with his yards per attempt and touchdown rate both falling more than 10% from his career highs in 2022. He made up for part of that dropoff with a career-high (and NFL record, shared with Josh Allen) 15 rushing touchdowns. We expect the arrival of Kellen Moore to be a positive for Hurts' passing efficiency and Saquon Barkley should do more with his targets than the running backs did last year as well. That should help make up for any regression in terms of rushing touchdowns. After all, we aren't entirely sure the tush push will work as well without Jason Kelce. Hurts' Dynasty floor is helped by the long-term deals signed by A.J. Brown and DeVonta Smith this offseason. Bottom line, if he is on your roster he better me in your line-up.

Gardner Minshew vs Chargers
- Minshew has been named the Raiders starting quarterback to begin the 2024 season. Minshew fit in well with the Colts in 2023 and settled in as a QB2 in Fantasy. While he had spike weeks (QB2 and QB6 finishes), he also struggled to finish weeks inside the top 12 at QB in all but three of his games. Minshew joins a Raiders group with talented pass catchers in Davante Adams, Brock Bowers and Jakobi Meyers, but what should also be a run-first offense under coach Antonio Pierce. Minshew is a back-end QB2 without long-term certainty as a starting option, so don't get too attached to him in SuperFlex leagues. As long as he is the starter, we do like him as an occasional low-priced DFS play or streamer in Superflex leagues. This could be one of those weeks as he takes on the Chargers who ranked #31 in passing yards allowed and #30 against fantasy QBs in 2023. For what it is worth, when he last played the Chargers, he passed for 215 and tossed 3 TD passes.

Tua Tagovailoa vs Colts
- Tagovailoa is a borderline QB1 worthy of a start in favorable match-ups. The Dolphins QB has shown flashes of the upside we believe exists in him, but never for a full season. Last year he was QB4 through the first eight weeks of the season and QB10 through Week 13. From that point forward he had just one game with more than 240 yards passing and just one game with multiple touchdown passes. That type of letdown in the Fantasy playoffs will surely cause some Fantasy managers to shy away, but he did finish with a league-best 4,624 passing yards and a second year in a row of about eight yards per attempt. With Mike McDaniel, Tyreek Hill and Jaylen Waddle all still in Miami, there is plenty of reason to hope that Tagovailoa maintains his breakout for a full season in 2024. The good news for Tua owners, of course, is that the season is brand new, which means that we can expect to see the "Good" Tua before the potential melt-down. So roll with him with confidence.


 Sound Off!

 Click here to visit our message boards and post your Sit or Start questions!

 

© 2025 ATC All rights reserved.